Propulsion Problem Causes Carnival Legend to Tilt

Carnival LegendLast Monday I received messages from a crew member friend on the Carnival Legend who said: "im on carnival legend / just as we are almost arriving in victoria canada 6:30 pm, local time, the ship experience a heavy swing towards the side / lots of things fell of in my cabin and for a second got scared then they made an announcement that there was a problem with an azipod on the stb side that caused that and nobody should be concerned and we will be on our way but the speed went down a lot was a bit scary but they say everything is fine  . . . / going very slow arriving late in victoria canada, all shore excursions are canceled." 

A few days later, I received an email from a passenger who described the listing incident as follows:

"I recently finished a one-week Alaska cruise out of Seattle from Tuesday, August 23 to Tuesday, August 30. All went well until the last evening. In accordance with the itinerary, the ship was headed to a final port of call evening at Victoria, BC.

At about 6:00 pm on Monday (August 29, 2016), I was sitting with a friend in a lounge when we felt the shop tilt and stay tilted. A few cups & napkins began sliding off tables. Looking out the windows near
to where we were seated, we could see only the upper sky. When I looked across the lounge to the windows on the other of the ship, all I could see was water, the sea, as though it were a wall facing us!

This tilt occurred while the ship was still traveling at speed, which made the sensation worse.

After about a moment the captain, one Captain Gazzano, addressed the passengers by the public address system. His command of English was so poor that I could only understand 2 or 3 words of what he said: propeller, engine, disengaged.

Immediately after the captain's address, the cruise director, Jaimie Dee, spoke over the public address system. She was superb, essentially re-saying in comprehensible English what the captain had tried to say.

After about 3 or 4 minutes, the ship was righted and slowed its speed.

As I was leaving the lounge to go to the second seating dinner, passengers was leaving the restaurant from the first seating. Some were chatting about the incident, saying that the plates sliding off the table was what made them frightened. I myself saw four or five cakes slide right out of the refrigerated display case in the lounge where I was seated during the incident.

After the ship was righted, the captain addressed the passengers once more as I recollect, perhaps twice. And again, immediately after the captain spoke, the cruise director spoke to re-state clearly what the captain had tried to say.

Apart from the frightening aspects of the mechanical failure, the inability of the captain to address the passengers in basic English was deplorable."

A reader sent also me a jink to a YouTube video taken by a passenger on the Carnival Legend at the time of the incident. He writes on YouTube: 

"Watch the water flow from the pools aboard the Carnival Legend. There was a failure in the ships propulsion system about an hour and a half away from Victoria, British Columbia on Sunday, August 28th, 2016 at around 6:00 pm PST. The ship started to list heavily to the port side. I just happened to be in the area when it happened. Instead if panicking, I decided to film it!"

Wikipedia, strangely enough, already has this description of the incident:

"On August 29, 2016 at approximately 6:15 pm PT while sailing to Victoria, British Columbia, the turning valve in one of the ship's four engines failed, causing the ship to make a hard starboard turn and listed 30 degrees to the port side, only 10 degrees away from capsizing the vessel. This caused hundreds of dishes to fall over and break and caused both pools to drain out and items to be thrown off the deck. Passengers were directed by crew members to all stand on the left side of the ship to even out the listing. Captain Giuseppe Gazzano had to manually control the ship towards Victoria. There were no reported serious injuries but the ship arrived at Victoria two hours behind schedule." 

Have a comment? Please join the discussion on our Facebook page.

September 3 2016 Update: Ship Tilts Cause Concern - Malfunctions In Auto-pilot Cited In Some Reports (prior incidents) via Sun Sentinel in 2006.

September 4 2016 Update: Other videos of the listing were posted by passengers on YouTube; credit Randy Gibbs YouTube page and Nate Kosch YouTube pages.

We recently received a longer explanation of what happened from another passenger on the cruise ship, who said, in part: 

"Towards the end of dinner we heard a ve loud mechanical noise and the ship began to shake violently. The ship then went into a sharp turn. The ship then began to list. I had figured since the seas were so calm it was likely an evasive maneuver to avoid hitting something. I had told my wife to brace for a possible impact. However, the ship continued to turn and continued to list at a greater degree and you could see the water line come up to the window. The entire ship made a creaking sound. We were seated at the aft port side of the dining room and had a good view. Glasses and plates began to fall and shatter. Then a Carnival crew member yelled out for everyone at dinner to get to the starboard side of the ship. My wife and I had already started to do so. The direction was the correct one so no criticism there, but the alarm in the crew member's voice was disconcerting. My wife then said we had to find the kids that she did not want them to be alone. We knew that both were with their kids clubs and where they were. We, and hundreds of others, left the Truffles dining room, there was some panic and shoving but overall not too bad under the circumstances. I had advised my wife to exit bygoing through the waiters serving area on the starboard side of the dining room. I did so for two reasons, one it was as far starboard as we could go, but if the ship tipped to its side, it would give us a barrier so we wouldn't slide across the width of the ship. Right before we stabilized into a stable port side list, it did feel as
though the ship may tip over. In fact, one woman yelled out, "my god we are going to tip over." We made our way out of the dining room somewhat consistently stepping on broken dishware and food. We went
up the stairs. On the third deck, many people had already began assembling at their muster stations, one crew member was directing people to do so. However, the general alarm had not sounded and we
were not going to the muster station without our kids

We made our way to the lido deck (deck nine) where my son was. He stated that they were all advised to go to the starboard side of the ship and did so, but that his counselor had left. He said he was not scared, but hugged us so we know he was. He said he was on his way to get his sister and then the muster station. We were most concerned about her since she was playing mini golf on an open deck
with her group. It was at this time, the captain got on the PA system and announced that, "nothing has happened," to which several passengers responded with expletives.

We were able to get to deck ten and find my daughter, she was visibly very upset. My daughter's counselor was about to take the children to their muster station and had prepared them for what to
expect. We were able to speak with my daughter and her friends afterwards. She had directed all on the deck to the starboard side. She originally advised the kids it was only a sharp turn, but at some point yelled out, "oh s--t." I can't blame her for her choice of words but again it underscored that the crew was alarmed. Two of the kids had stumbled while on the way to the starboard side. One fell into the net roping off the basketball court, one slide part way down the deck. The basketball and several golf balls went over the side of the deck. Shortly thereafter, the ship had been stabilized and was now slightly listing to the starboard side, likely a slight overcompensation. We spoke to one of our daughter's friend's parents
later. They were on the first floor, their room was completely underwater. (There is at least one deck below deck one where there are crew quarters). They had put on their life vests and headed to their
muster station. I have travelled extensively by sea and air and have never seen anything like this before.

Before we got underway later that evening, we went to guest services for an explanation. By the time we were done we had gotten four different ones, that it was the stabilizers, it was the propulsion system, it was the steering system, and finally that nothing had really happened. They advised nothing like this had ever happened before, but we later found out that this has happened at least once prior on the Carnival Legend. They were unapologetic and unmoved. They denied that any crew members directed people to their muster stations. This was simply not true. We called Carnival again today. We received a similar response. The representative said they really can't do anything about it because everyone on the ship was affected. We received no explanation, no apology, and were informed we would not receive a follow-up phone call from anyone. There would simply be too many people to call. It is as though they want to cover it up. Perhaps the situation was not as bad as believed at the time. In reading, apparently this happens from time to time. However, generally it is a weather event which this was not. Rarely it is
significant mechanical failure which this appeared to be. A listing of only 14% can cause dishes and plates to fall and shatter and apparently a cruise ship can sustain up to a 40% before it capsizes. Nonetheless it was pretty scary at the time and we were shaken . . .  

. . . Only Carnival can manage to have an incident in near perfect weather and seas. It would have been more understandably if it was the weather . . ."

September 5 2018 Update: The listing incident was picked up by CHEK media in Canada: Pools drain, dishes fly in cruise ship incident near Victoria.  The Times-Colonist also published: Passengers ‘freaked out’ after cruise ship lists 30 degrees near Victoria.

Photo credit: By Robertsrules - Own work, CC BY 3.0.

Video credit: Jerry Janes YouTube 

 

 

Trackbacks (0) Links to blogs that reference this article Trackback URL
http://www.cruiselawnews.com/admin/trackback/323746
Comments (14) Read through and enter the discussion with the form at the end
KNUT HAGE-HANSEN - September 3, 2016 7:47 PM

DEAR ALL "AMERICANS...", NOT ONLY FOREIGNERS TALK AND
W R I T E "ENGLISH" BAD..., ALSO MANY YOUNG AMERICANS...
BUT I DO UNDERSTAND "YOUR CONCERN HERE..."

WELL IT WILL BE BETTER WHEN US COMPANIES PAY THEIR
TAXES TO "REST OF THE WORLD...", F.EX. EUROPE...

ITS GOOD WE HAVE SO MANY DIFFERENT PEOPLE AROUND THIS LOVELY PLANET...

BEST RGDS
KHH

SQUAREHEADED SCANDINAVIAN...

Kaloyan - September 4, 2016 2:22 PM

Crnival drama never end ...

BigMac - September 4, 2016 3:14 PM

@KNUT HAGE-HANSEN

The Captain of a USA based company/ship who is in overall charge of a ship with mainly English speaking passengers onboard SHOULD be able to communicate in an understandable manner, if not just for safety reasons during an emergency.

The companies official language is English, and this applies to everybody.

Whether other people can speak English or not has nothing to do with what could have been a possibly really bad situation.

Carol Rozek - September 5, 2016 10:52 AM

I was on the Carnival Legend when this incident happened in the Red Frog Pub and we could clearly hear and understand what the Captain was saying. He spoke clear English with an Italian accent. His English was better than several passengers English. While I agree that depending where you were on the ship and the background noises in your particular area could have had an effect on how well YOU heard what he was saying,he did speak clearly in explaining what happened.

A Brown - September 5, 2016 5:22 PM

The ships stabilizer must have been triggered to engage, may be to correct a slight tilt say to the port side. (Depending on its control mechanism)
The correct command from the bridge is to give an emergency stop of the main propulsion engines
This would bring the ship to a stop and right the ship, as there would be no flow of water over the stabilizers, to cause any tilt to the ship. The next command is too mechanical disengage the stabilizers. See that they are out of service, then proceed with the main engine to you next port. That is to say that there is nothing wrong with the control of the main engines or the propeller pods, if they are used to steer the ship

David - September 6, 2016 4:21 PM

There is no possibility that the captain of a Carnival ship doesn't speak English. It may be accented, but it will be perfectly understandable.

Jim Walker - September 6, 2016 4:24 PM

David:

You can hear the captain talking over the intercom after the list, in the last video at the bottom.

You can determine whether he can be understood, or not, particularly contrasted to the cruise director.

In the video, the dad says "what did they say? which is repeated by a child and then the mom says "I don't know."

David - September 6, 2016 11:26 PM

I don't know, Jim

The captain's message seemed pretty clear to me. The cruise director's message was clearer in the video, but then again the person taking the video and his children weren't talking over it and she is a native English speaker.

John Fuhrman - September 7, 2016 8:23 PM

I was on this Carnival and my family was lucky enough to get to meet and chat with the captain many times that week, along with his family. He spoke English very well with an Italian accent. We were in the main lobby when this all happened and as freightening as it was you have to understand that the captain was just as startled as we were making his accent much stronger and harder to comprehend. Also, his family was on board that ship so I'm sure he was very worried about them too.

Susan marcantel - September 8, 2016 11:03 PM

We were located on the 3rd deck and had difficulty understanding the announcement made by the captain, had we been in our room on the 5th deck we would not have heard it at all. To hear an announcement clearly depended where you were. Until this article we still had no idea what happened to the ship, but I have to agree it was handled well even though we didn't even attempt to go to our muster station, life jackets which were in our room was also out of the question, we did not want to go into stairwells or use the elevator.

Colin Ratcliffe - September 11, 2016 5:00 PM

We were on the cruise and everything that has been said so far is true, the incident was very alarming & there was very little information about the event either at the time or later. It was as if it was nothing had happened and now I learn that it was a serious incident . You would think that Carnival would have been in contact after our return.

Karen Baker - September 13, 2016 1:09 PM

I was on the Legend during this incident. Yes, the captain had an accent, but I'm finding it hard to believe the main concern being voiced here is the captains accent. Is no one concerned, or freaked out, about the ship tilting and Carnival not telling the truth about it? The news reports that I have seen are stating it was an 8 degree list. What I would like to know is if it was only a 8 degree list as most of the news reports are stating, how did all the water in the pools drain? There is an 12-15 inch wall around the pools. The water needed to get over that wall and then drain over the sides like seen in the video. I am a Canadian and as in Canadian custom, you apologize for freaking people out. I'm expecting an apology from Carnival.

Alan Szekely - September 17, 2016 9:56 AM

My wife and I were on this cruise and in the dining room eating dinner on deck three when this incident occurred. A very load vibration followed by obvious mechanical failure was our first indication that something was wrong. The crew told us to remain calm and stay where we were but from the looks on they're faces something was seriously wrong. I took my wife's hand and exited the dining room to the outside area a quickly as possible. I am not a maritime expert but have been on several cruises with carnival but feel like this was close to extreme tragedy and felt extreme fear as never before on a cruise ship. Don't be fooled this ship is in serious need of a mechanical overhaul and I will never set foot on an old bucket of bolts like this one again!

Jen - July 27, 2017 12:29 AM

Well, it happened again, on 7/24. 2017. afternoon on way to Victoria BC on Legend Cruise. I specifically Called Carnival before booking this cruise and got them to assure me the legend was fit and safe and it shouldn't happen ever again. I was on the Lido deck with Cruise director Jen in charge of the groove for St Jude. a very loud noise, followed by the pools emptying and Jen looked concerned and had the assistant arry on collecting St. Judes donations while she went off to check on things. Then an announcement that all was well. But is was the same, and it was scary. I really thought we were going to tip over.

Post A Comment / Question Use this form to add a comment to this entry.







Remember personal info?