"Strip Search" Lawsuit: Court Denies Carnival's Motion to Sanction Teenager for Telling Lies

A federal judge denied Carnival Cruise Lines' motion to punish a teenager who admitted that she lied when claiming that the cruise ship's security personnel forced her to remove her tampon in a search for marijuana.  

Courthouse News Service reports that one of Carnival's security officers noticed that a 17-year-old passenger on Sensation cruise ship dropped a container of what he believed to be marijuana in an elevator.

The chief security officer subsequently ordered a search of the girl's cabin. This is when the girl claimed that a female security officer strip-searched her and made her remove her underwear and tampon. The search apparently took place without the girl's mother present.

The minor and her mother were removed from the cruise ship. The girl spent the night and most of the next day in jail in the Bahamas until the U.S. Embassy intervened and the girl was released.

A lawsuit followed and the case headed to trial. But during trial, the girl testified that although she felt like she "had to" take off her underwear and remove her tampon, she admitted that she voluntarily did so that the search "would be over with."

After a jury found for Carnival, the cruise line sought to punish the girl by forcing her to pay all of the the cruise line's attorney fees. The federal court refused to impose the sanctions sought by Carnival, citing her young age and her efforts to set the record straight. The judge also found that the girl was under the influence of her mother who encouraged her to pursue the legal claim in the first place.

The court also took into consideration that the young woman, now 19, is unemployed and is a student on financial aid at a small college. The court already taxed costs of $4,364.06 against her out of the $9,305.14 sought by Carnival.  The court concluded that fining her additional money for the cruise giant's attorney fees would be meaningless.    

You can read the order here

 

Photo Credit: Wknight94 via Wikipedia

Trackbacks (0) Links to blogs that reference this article Trackback URL
http://www.cruiselawnews.com/admin/trackback/307257
Comments (2) Read through and enter the discussion with the form at the end
KAI UNGAS - October 31, 2013 10:54 PM

the mother of the minor tolerates the irregularities behavior of her daughter that is why she lied.Do not ever ever mess with the security officers specially in carnival cruise lines. Security officers on the ship making sure the safety and security of every individual on board.

Stir Fry - February 20, 2014 8:02 PM

So this is how Carnival security decides to flex its muscle?

How about focusing on crime prevention and crime solving including background checks for crew?

Sounds like someone wanted to get their jollies by harassing a teenager and they actually put her in jail!?

More disgraceful and misdirected behavior by Carnival and the Bahamas who probably made a buck off it it.

Post A Comment / Question Use this form to add a comment to this entry.







Remember personal info?
Send To A Friend Use this form to send this entry to a friend via email.