Violence on Carnival's Freedom Reveals Need for Independent Law Enforcement

A reader of Cruise Law News brought to my attention today a disturbing story found in a cruise review on Cruise Critic. It's written by the mother of four sons who were sailing with a group of seven on the Carnival Freedom this month. 

The review is titled Anarchy on the Freedom.  Take a moment and read it. Mom's two oldest sons, age 22 and 19, were taunted in a nightclub and then viciously assaulted and beaten while they were trying to leave, by an adult and a group of teenagers. The older boy was "was attacked from behind, his hands held behind his back, struck several times on the head and ribs, kicked and then tossed down a flight of stairs . . . "

But Mom was not just concerned that her children were physically beaten but by the way that Carnival treated them afterward.  She was given the run-around, lied to by security, refused the names of the assailants, denied a copy of the security report and told that there were no surveillance video.  Her Fight Aboard Carnival Freedom Cruise Shipoptions were to either hire a lawyer or contact the FBI - neither particularly attractive options I am sure. 

As outrageous as all of this sounds, this is the usual outcome when there is a brawl on a Carnival cruise ship.    

I have attended seven Congressional hearings in Washington D.C. regarding cruise ship safety issues since December 2005. One of the recurring issues discussed before Congress is crime and the cruise lines' failure to respond to the problem.

Yes, you can have an awful lot of fun on a cruise.  But there is no denying that crime occurs on cruise ships. The difference between land based crimes and shipboard crimes is that there is no sense of accountability on cruise ships. Lawlessness prevails.  

The cruise industry states that the "safety of cruise passengers is its highest priority," but that is not remotely true. If you are a victim of a rape or a violent physical assault and battery during a cruise, there is well over a 95% probability that your assailant will not be arrested or prosecuted.  

This is because there are no police officers or sheriff deputies on the high seas. The FBI technically has jurisdiction to investigate crimes involving Americans on cruise ships, even though the ships fly foreign flags of convenience and even when the crimes occur in international waters. But the truth of the matter is that the FBI is not interested in crimes on cruise ships.  Fewer than 5% of cruise ship crimes are ever prosecuted by our federal government.

This leaves the matter of crimes in the hands of the cruise ship security personnel.  Their job, however, is not to arrest anyone but to try and keep a lid on the problem until the cruise ship returns to port where they can get the warring  parties off the ship and then re-rack for another 7 day drunken cruise to Mexico.  

The International Cruise Victims organization has suggested that a law be passed requiring independent law enforcement officers aboard cruise ships, to investigate crimes and hold the bad guys accountable. The cruise lines have fought this vigorously.

The result is what unfolded this month on the Carnival Freedom.  


For other stories like this, consider reading:

More Cruise Ship Violence - A Drunken Brawl On Carnival's Dream

Out of Control Cruise Ship Drinking & Violence

Trackbacks (0) Links to blogs that reference this article Trackback URL
Comments (8) Read through and enter the discussion with the form at the end
Isabel - July 31, 2012 10:42 AM

Appears to be a stressful environment, our last cruise
with royal the dining staff were fighting for the equipment all week long etc,

sef foruma - July 31, 2012 1:42 PM

It is a standard practice to deny a copy of the security report, because at the time, the crime was still being investigated. She can ask for one later on, from Carnival customers relations department.
Second, no cruise ship is cover with surveillance 100%.
Besides, if a camera captures an incident, that video is a material evidence, and is legally obtainable by a lawyer only. That's how it works on land too.
BTW, what was a 19 yrs old doing in a night club? Last time I heard, you have to be 21 to enter.

Jim Walker - July 31, 2012 2:36 PM


Carnival, like all other cruise lines, will never voluntarily release a security report of a crime. The cruise lines consider such reports to be confidential and privileged, done in anticipation of defending a lawsuit that the passengers may bring.

The problem with CCTV images is that they tend to disappear magically, or the recording device was not working, or the dog ate it.

Good question about a 19 year old in a bar. That happens a lot too, under-age kids permitted where they shouldn't be due to the lack of security.

Regards Jim Walker

Juanito - July 31, 2012 7:56 PM

I suspect that drinking age on cruise ships is based on the registration country. Liberia, Ecuador, the Bahamas, etc probably have a drinking age of 18.

Back when I was a young reprobate living in southern California, my friends and I used to go to Mexico so we could drink legally under 21.

sef foruma - August 1, 2012 5:25 AM

Juanito, not quite, this is from a cruise ship -

Amanda - August 4, 2012 9:10 AM

I work for a cruise line and if there is an incident on board such as a rape. The police are waiting at the pier when the ship arrives. You can also be kicked off the ship at the next port of call. The drinking age is 21 it doesnt matter where the ship is registered.

rhonda - August 17, 2012 12:21 AM

wonder if people stop cruising for 6 months maybe the cruise lines will think more into whats going on some of these ships. i cruise some and now i am afraid of either being on ship or other various ports..i regularly read cruise critic and did read the article and at first i thought no way,but something needs to be done here.I feel if things that can be avoided on cruises continue to happen i might look at a diff type of vacation.

C Carnes - August 9, 2017 2:06 PM


Post A Comment / Question Use this form to add a comment to this entry.

Remember personal info?