Cruise Ship Dangers: A Reckless Maneuver On A Calm Day

Cruise Expert Professor Ross Klein has one of the most exhaustive and informative web sites for all of the things that go wrong on cruise ships.  

This weekend I read this comment from a reader of his site about an encounter between a MSC container ship and a MSC cruise ship, the MSC Lirica.  It seems that the Italian shipping company has a tradition of their ship "buzzing" each  other, not unlike "saluting" an island like the Italian cruise ship the Concordia did to the island of Giglio.     

The following are the comments and photographs from a cruise passenger aboard the Lirica who observed the incident.  Very dramatic and potentially very dangerous.  Credit to Professor Klein's cruisejunkie web site.

"On 25 March the MSC LIRICA was overtaken by a container ship, the MSC LAUREN, in a very close quarter situation. Weather conditions were fine and seas were open. The ship was sailing south of Sicily at about 17 kts on a voyage from Kuwait to Hamburg. As we know since the sinking of the Costa Concordia and the claims of Capt. Schettino, that his company and others like to pass extremely close certain geographical co-ordinates, the same seems to be the philosophy of another cruise ship company too - to meet company ships as well as in a close-up situation of less than 100 meters. The MSC LAUREN approached the MSC LIRICA from starboard aft - she came closer and closer and once the LAUREN was abeam the distance was less than one cable. Whistles were blowing, passengers waving and none of them was aware about the high risk in case of a blackout or engine or rudder-failure on one of the ships. This practice is inconsistent (with) good bridge management practices.

MSC Lirica versus MSC Lauren

MSC Lirica versus MSC Lauren

Anyone else see a maneuver like this between two ships?

Trackbacks (0) Links to blogs that reference this article Trackback URL
http://www.cruiselawnews.com/admin/trackback/275487
Comments (2) Read through and enter the discussion with the form at the end
K Rogers - October 24, 2012 10:16 AM

Has MSC seen this? I am on the Lirica next week and this scares me.

Dave - December 20, 2012 6:45 PM

what you cannot tell is how close the ship is due to the camera angle of the person taking it! had it been taken over the side rail then you woul dhave the real view of the distance between the ships,I have a photo from May 2012 of a Costa ship leaving Athens Greece passing our ship the NCL Jade, because of the angle it is taken from it looks as though the Costa ship is touching the Jade!

Post A Comment / Question Use this form to add a comment to this entry.







Remember personal info?
Send To A Friend Use this form to send this entry to a friend via email.